subperiosteal implants
Titanium and polyether ether ketone (PEEK) patient-specific subperiosteal implants: two novel approaches for rehabilitation of the severely atrophic anterior maxillary ridge
- 28 December 2017
- Posted by: Subperiosteal Institute
- Category: Other Materials
M. Mounir, M. Atef, A. Abou-Elfetouh, M.M. Hakam
Full text link: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29183698/
Titanium and Polyether Ether Ketone (PEEK) Patient-Specific Subperiosteal Implants: Two Novel Approaches for Rehabilitation of the Severely Atrophic Anterior Maxillary Ridge
1. Scientific Reference
- Study Title: Titanium and Polyether Ether Ketone (PEEK) Patient-Specific Subperiosteal Implants: Two Novel Approaches for Rehabilitation of the Severely Atrophic Anterior Maxillary Ridge
- Authors: M. Mounir, M. Atef, A. Abou-Elfetouh, M.M. Hakam
- Journal: International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
- Year of Publication: 2018
- DOI: 10.1016/j.ijom.2017.11.008
2. Scientific Background
Management of severe anterior maxillary atrophy remains one of the most demanding challenges in implant dentistry and oral rehabilitation. In many cases, the residual alveolar bone volume is insufficient for the placement of conventional endosseous implants, requiring extensive bone augmentation procedures before implant-supported restoration can be considered.
Although grafting techniques have expanded the treatment possibilities for severely resorbed ridges, these procedures often involve multiple surgical stages, increased treatment duration, additional costs, and the potential for biological complications. Consequently, there is ongoing interest in alternative treatment approaches capable of reducing surgical complexity while maintaining functional rehabilitation outcomes.
Advances in digital workflows, three-dimensional imaging, CAD/CAM planning, and additive manufacturing have renewed attention toward patient-specific subperiosteal implants. These technologies enable the fabrication of customized frameworks designed to adapt precisely to individual anatomical conditions. The present study investigates this modern evolution of subperiosteal implant therapy using two different biomaterials: porous titanium and polyether ether ketone (PEEK).
3. Study Objective
The primary objective of this clinical investigation was to evaluate two customized subperiosteal implant protocols for the rehabilitation of patients presenting with severe anterior maxillary atrophy.
Specifically, the authors assessed the clinical performance of patient-specific porous titanium implants and patient-specific PEEK implants manufactured through CAD/CAM-based technologies and used within a single-stage rehabilitation protocol.
4. Methodology
This was a single-center observational clinical study.
Ten patients presenting with multiple missing anterior maxillary teeth and severe horizontal and vertical bone deficiency were enrolled. Participants were randomly allocated into two equal groups:
- Group 1: Customized porous titanium subperiosteal implants.
- Group 2: Customized PEEK subperiosteal implants.
Each patient underwent CT-based virtual planning. Three-dimensional anatomical models were generated using dedicated image-processing software, allowing the design of individualized subperiosteal frameworks and integrated abutments. The implants were subsequently manufactured using advanced additive manufacturing technologies.
Fixed acrylic prosthetic restorations were delivered approximately one month after surgery. Clinical and radiographic follow-up was conducted over a 12-month period. Outcomes included implant stability, mobility, infection, implant exposure, prosthetic complications, and radiographic evaluation of supporting bone levels.
5. Main Results
Overall, clinical outcomes were favorable in both treatment groups.
Only one patient in the titanium group experienced postoperative wound dehiscence associated with partial implant exposure. Following local management and strict oral hygiene measures, healing progressed satisfactorily and prosthetic loading was ultimately completed.
At the 12-month evaluation, all implants remained functional and clinically stable. No cases of implant mobility, infection, or prosthetic fracture were reported. Patients maintained their fixed restorations throughout the follow-up period and were described as comfortable with their prostheses.
Radiographic comparison between immediate postoperative and one-year panoramic examinations revealed no evident changes in supporting bone levels around the subperiosteal implants. Within the limits of the study, both porous titanium and PEEK customized implants demonstrated satisfactory short-term clinical performance.
6. Clinical Analysis
This study is particularly relevant because it revisits the concept of subperiosteal implants through the lens of contemporary digital implantology. Historically, subperiosteal implants lost favor due to concerns regarding fit accuracy, fixation, biological complications, and long-term predictability. The integration of modern imaging, digital planning, and additive manufacturing may address several of these historical limitations.
The findings suggest that customized subperiosteal implants could provide a viable rehabilitation strategy for selected patients with severe anterior maxillary atrophy who would otherwise require extensive bone reconstruction procedures. The ability to design implants directly from patient-specific anatomical data represents a significant advancement in personalized implant therapy.
The investigation also provides preliminary clinical information regarding two different biomaterials. Porous titanium was selected because of its favorable mechanical characteristics and potential for bone integration, while PEEK was investigated because its elastic properties more closely resemble those of natural bone and may theoretically reduce stress-shielding effects.
Despite these encouraging observations, caution remains essential. The sample size was limited, follow-up was restricted to one year, and no control group was included. Consequently, the results should be viewed as preliminary evidence supporting further clinical investigation rather than definitive validation of the technique.
7. Clinical Applications
The findings may be relevant in several challenging clinical situations, including:
- Severe anterior maxillary atrophy.
- Patients with inadequate bone volume for conventional implant placement.
- Cases where extensive bone grafting procedures are undesirable or difficult to perform.
- Digitally planned implant rehabilitation workflows.
- CAD/CAM-based patient-specific implant solutions.
- Fixed implant-supported rehabilitation of complex edentulous sites.
The study specifically evaluated the anterior maxilla; therefore, the applicability of these results to other anatomical regions cannot be established from the available data.
8. Level of Evidence, Limitations, and Transparency
This publication represents an observational clinical study involving a limited number of patients.
From an evidence-based dentistry perspective, the level of evidence is lower than that provided by randomized controlled trials, systematic reviews, or meta-analyses. The findings should therefore be interpreted as preliminary clinical data.
Several methodological limitations are identifiable:
- Small sample size (10 patients).
- Absence of a control group treated with alternative rehabilitation methods.
- Follow-up limited to 12 months.
- Single-center design.
The authors state that the study was self-funded. No competing interests were declared in the information provided.
9. Key Study Highlights
- Study type: Single-center observational clinical study.
- Level of evidence: Prospective case-series level evidence with comparative groups.
- Population: Patients with severe anterior maxillary atrophy.
- Number of patients: 10.
- Number of implants: 10 customized subperiosteal implants.
- Follow-up period: 12 months.
- Primary outcome assessed: Clinical and radiographic implant stability.
- Main finding: All implants remained functional and stable at one year.
- Reported complication: One postoperative wound dehiscence in the titanium group.
- Scientific conclusion: Customized porous titanium and customized PEEK subperiosteal implants demonstrated acceptable short-term clinical performance for rehabilitation of severely atrophic anterior maxillae.
- Key limitations: Small sample size, short follow-up period, and lack of control group.
10. Scientific Impact
The significance of this study lies in its contribution to the modern re-emergence of subperiosteal implant therapy through digital technologies. Rather than relying on traditional fabrication methods, the authors implemented a fully digital workflow incorporating CT imaging, virtual planning, CAD/CAM design, and advanced manufacturing techniques.
The work also provides early clinical data comparing two distinct materials within the same therapeutic concept. By evaluating both porous titanium and PEEK, the study expands the discussion regarding material selection for patient-specific implant rehabilitation.
Although limited in scale, the findings support continued investigation into customized implant solutions for severely atrophic maxillary ridges. The study may be viewed as an exploratory contribution that helps establish the feasibility of digitally manufactured subperiosteal implants and encourages future research with larger cohorts and longer observation periods.
11. Editorial Conclusion
This clinical study explores an innovative approach to the rehabilitation of severely atrophic anterior maxillae through the use of digitally designed patient-specific subperiosteal implants. Both porous titanium and PEEK frameworks demonstrated favorable short-term clinical and radiographic outcomes over a 12-month follow-up period. While the limited sample size and relatively short observation period prevent broad clinical conclusions, the findings contribute valuable preliminary evidence supporting the potential role of customized CAD/CAM-based implant solutions in complex implant rehabilitation cases.
